One-Line Summary
Belinda Bauer’s The Impossible Thing proves that a great crime novel needn’t begin with murder.
Opening Impression
It begins with an obsession — a rare egg, crimson and delicate, dangling between beauty and destruction. Bauer transforms this peculiar fascination into a meditation on greed, ecology, and the echoes of human desire across time. Few writers blend emotional empathy with forensic precision as she does. Her prose glides effortlessly between eras, turning the seemingly small world of egg-collecting into a vast moral landscape.
Synopsis
In 1926, on the Yorkshire cliffs, twelve-year-old Celie Sheppard is sent down perilous ropes to gather seabird eggs for gentlemen collectors who pay handsomely for what she risks her life to steal. Among the wind and salt, she discovers a crimson guillemot egg so rare it will haunt generations. A century later in rural Wales, Patrick Fort and his friend Nick discover that someone has broken into Nick’s cottage — taking nothing except an old carved box containing a single egg. When Patrick’s curiosity turns into investigation, the pair stumble into a black-market trade that stretches from collectors’ cabinets to museum archives. As the two stories spiral closer together, Bauer reveals the devastating continuity between past exploitation and present-day obsession.
Analysis
Literary Evaluation:
Structure: The novel alternates with clockwork precision between historical and contemporary strands, each reflecting the other without redundancy. Bauer controls pacing like a composer, letting tension accrue through parallel discoveries rather than shock reveals.
Characterisation: Celie’s voice — innocent, determined, and heartbreakingly pragmatic — anchors the past narrative. Patrick Fort, familiar from Bauer’s earlier work, remains one of crime fiction’s most original figures: neurodivergent, literal, and guided by an unerring sense of justice. Their shared trait is curiosity unsoftened by cynicism.
Style & Voice: Bauer’s prose balances lyricism and restraint. The sensory detail of chalk cliffs, gull cries, and rain-slicked fields creates a physical world rich enough to smell. Dialogue, often understated, carries humour and melancholy in equal measure. The result is an atmosphere at once intimate and epic — crime fiction written with the cadence of literary history.
Themes: Obsession, exploitation, and inheritance — how human appetite consumes the natural world and how truth, like an egg, is both fragile and fiercely protected. The 'impossible thing' becomes a metaphor for innocence in a world that profits from its loss.
Verdict
The Impossible Thing is a marvel of construction and compassion. It fuses ecological awareness with mystery plotting, demonstrating that the most dangerous crimes are often committed quietly and remembered poorly. Bauer turns her lens from forensic laboratories to living landscapes, revealing how guilt endures in the soil and sea spray. Lyrical, humane, and quietly devastating, this novel stands among her finest — a reminder that in the smallest objects lie the grandest moral questions.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.