One-Line Summary
When Anna Matheson lures six former colleagues onto a private night train, a supposed charity gala becomes a locked-room reckoning—secrets, power, and revenge hurtling toward an unavoidable crash.
Opening Impression
With a Vengeance begins with the elegance of a classic mystery and the pulse of a modern revenge thriller. A luxury train cutting through the American night becomes a crucible for guilt, class, and justice. Six guests board believing they are attending an exclusive charity event; by the time the train reaches its first stop, one of them will be dead and the hostess unmasked as their reckoning. Matheson writes with Hitchcockian control—every corridor, every glass of champagne, every polite smile conceals a blade. Beneath the sleek premise lies something darker: a study of how vengeance corrodes even the righteous. The opening chapters evoke Agatha Christie’s poise but steeped in twenty-first-century cynicism; civility and cruelty share the same carriage.
Synopsis
Each invitee helped engineer the corporate collapse that ruined Anna’s family and destroyed her father’s life. The journey from Philadelphia to Savannah is meant to be their confession chamber. But as the train hurtles south, her meticulous plan wobbles. A sudden power failure plunges the carriages into darkness; when the lights return, one guest lies dead. With the train locked down and communications cut, Anna is forced into the role she despises—the investigator—while concealing her own motive. The surviving passengers—bankers, lawyers, a journalist, a former lover—turn on one another, their past dealings revealed through flashbacks that widen the moral labyrinth. Polished brass and mahogany mask panic; the track’s rhythmic clatter becomes a metronome counting down to exposure. By the terminus, vengeance has taken a shape Anna never imagined—one that spares no one, least of all herself.
Analysis
Structure: A confined, linear timeline mirrors the train’s forward motion. Chapters alternate between present-tense claustrophobia and past-tense revelations, tightening the screws on motive and memory.
Characterisation: Anna is both architect and prisoner of her own revenge—intelligent, brittle, and self-aware enough to know she’s past redemption. The ensemble cast functions like mirrors, reflecting facets of her guilt and anger rather than serving as mere victims.
Style & Voice: Precise and cinematic, written in visual beats—doorways, reflections, the flicker of passing lights. Dialogue carries the rhythm of interrogation; silence does the real talking. Think Gillian Flynn filtered through Patricia Highsmith.
Themes: Retribution, moral decay, power, and the illusion of control. The locked-room format becomes allegory: when walls close in, everyone’s truth becomes a weapon.
Verdict
With a Vengeance is an ingeniously constructed revenge thriller that asks what happens when justice and obsession share the same destination. Matheson reinvents the “murder on a train” trope as psychological autopsy, using luxury as camouflage for rot. The plotting is taut, the character work merciless, and the finale both shocking and inevitable. Beneath the suspense beats a moral engine: revenge promises closure but delivers only reflection. Stylish, claustrophobic, and emotionally unsparing—this marks Anna Matheson as a storyteller who knows the most dangerous journey is the one inward.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.